Why spirituality won’t carry what religion and discipleship to Jesus carry
There’s a moment in Faith, Hope and Carnage where Nick Cave describes a candle in a church. He’s been wrecked by the deaths of his sons Arthur and Jethro. The act is simple. He lights a candle, kneels, sits among strangers who’ve done this for two thousand years. He says it does something. The wax, the smoke, the cold stone, the shape of the place, the company of people whose grief came before his and will come after.
A wellness app cannot give him this. Neither can a manifestation journal, an ayahuasca retreat, a curated playlist of Tibetan singing bowls, or the bookstore section labeled spirituality. The question Cave keeps returning to in the Red Hand Files is why. Why does the church hold him when the alternatives don’t.
His answer, gathered across years of letters and interviews, is the same answer Marilynne Robinson gives in her essays, that Tara Isabella Burton gives in Strange Rites, that Jonathan Sacks gave in book after book before he died, that Charles Taylor gives in A Secular Age, that David Bentley Hart gives with his usual baroque ferocity. It’s also the answer the Church Fathers and Mothers gave, and the answer Jesus gave on a hillside outside Jerusalem when he told the rich young man to sell everything. The answer takes many forms but holds a single shape.
Religion costs you something. Spirituality, in its contemporary therapeutic form, costs you $19.99 plus shipping.
The Wellness Aisle
Walk into any large bookstore. The spirituality section is now bigger than the religion section. The books have soft covers in muted colors. They have one-word titles: Breathe. Glow. Bloom. They promise integration, alignment, awakening, your highest self. They’re written by people who’ve figured something out and would like to share it for $26.
There’s a logic to this market. People want meaning. They want practices. They want to feel that something larger holds them. They’ve, mostly, lost the inherited furniture of belief that their grandparents took for granted. So they buy what’s on offer.
What’s on offer is a customizable, low-friction, self-affirming experience of the sacred. You select the parts that resonate. You skip the parts that don’t. You retain veto power. The teacher is always you. The doctrine is whatever you’d already prefer to believe, with new vocabulary attached. There’s no congregation to disagree with you, no scripture older than your preferences, no priest to tell you the prayer you’ve been saying is wrong.
This is what Tara Isabella Burton calls bespoke religion in Strange Rites. The unbundling of religious life into atomized practices, each chosen for its therapeutic yield, with the consumer as final arbiter. Burton describes how the American religious imagination has migrated into SoulCycle, astrology apps, witchcraft TikTok, and the wellness-industrial complex. These provide some of what religion once provided: ritual, identity, community, transcendence-flavored experience. They do so on the consumer’s terms.
Charles Taylor, in A Secular Age, calls this condition the immanent frame. The horizon of meaning has closed. The transcendent still presses against the glass, and people still feel its pull. So they build little chapels inside the frame, lit by their own preferences. The shape of the longing remains. The object the longing pointed toward has been replaced by an experience of longing-as-such, marketed back to you with essential oils.
Religion Asks for Your Life
Now read the Sermon on the Mount.
“Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me.” Not your truth. Your cross. The wooden thing on which you die.
The teaching of Jesus has none of the soft contours of contemporary spirituality. He tells the rich young man to sell everything and give it to the poor. He tells his disciples that following him will divide families. He blesses the poor and the persecuted and warns the comfortable. He kneels and washes feet. He goes willingly to a Roman cross. The Sermon on the Mount lists demands so steep that Dietrich Bonhoeffer said any Christianity that softens them has stopped being Christianity.
Paul, writing to the Corinthians, calls the cross foolishness to the Greeks and a stumbling block to the Jews. He’s describing what religion offers in any age: something that looks insane from outside. A crucified peasant as Lord of the cosmos. A bowl of bread and wine as the body and blood of God. An obligation to love your enemies, forgive seventy times seven, and prefer the poor to the powerful.
James pushes further. Faith without works is dead. You don’t get to believe in private. You get to feed people, visit prisoners, bury the dead, sit with widows. The body of Christ has hands and feet, and they’re yours, and they get tired.
This is the structure Cave keeps gesturing at. Religion makes claims on your time, your money, your body, your loyalties, your ego. It puts you in a room with people you didn’t choose and asks you to call them brother and sister. It puts ancient words in your mouth and asks you to mean them. It tells you that you are a sinner, which is a humiliation no wellness app would ever inflict on a paying customer.
Having broken you down, religion offers something the wellness aisle has no machinery to offer: the possibility that you’ve been seen, judged, and loved anyway. By a God who’s real. Who’s a Person, not a metaphor for your inner light.
The Witnesses
The Desert Mothers and Fathers fled to the wastes of Egypt in the fourth century because they thought the church had grown too comfortable under Constantine. They went to hard places to practice hard prayer. Amma Syncletica taught that those who come near God face struggle at the beginning, as one lights a fire by friction. You’ll weep. You’ll be tested. You’ll want to leave. Only then does the fire catch.
A wellness retreat would describe this experience and call it inadvisable. The Desert Mothers called it Tuesday.
Julian of Norwich, anchored in a cell in fourteenth-century Norwich, received visions of Christ’s wounds during a near-fatal illness. Her Revelations of Divine Love include the famous line, “All shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well.” Pull that line out of context and it sounds like a fridge magnet. Read it in context and it’s something else entirely. Julian has just spent pages describing the body of Christ in agony, the weight of sin, the depth of human cruelty. The line comes from inside the worst. She’s making a claim that even at the bottom there’s a love that holds. The promise carries the weight of everything she has just described.
That love is what Cave is reaching for when he describes his church visits. The candle, the cold stone, the company of the dead. The promise made from inside the worst.
John of the Cross wrote about the dark night of the soul: the long stretch where God seems absent, prayer feels like talking to wallpaper, and the consolations of faith dry up entirely. His point was that this is normal. The dark night is part of the path. A spirituality that promises continuous good vibes has no category for this experience. It will tell you to try a different crystal, change your diet, find a new guru. Religion will tell you to keep showing up to the same place at the same time and saying the same words even though they feel like sawdust in your mouth, because that’s what love sometimes requires.
Augustine, looking back on his decades of brilliant restlessness in the Confessions, wrote, “You have made us for yourself, O Lord, and our heart is restless until it rests in you.” The diagnosis has held for sixteen centuries. The restless heart still tries every available object. Augustine tried Manichaeism, Neoplatonism, ambition, sex, prestige. He found rest only when he stopped trying to engineer the rest himself and let himself be claimed.
Brother Lawrence, a seventeenth-century lay brother who washed dishes in a Carmelite monastery in Paris, wrote about practicing the presence of God while scrubbing pots. His teaching has been absorbed into mindfulness culture, often stripped of its content. The original version assumed an actual God who was actually present, to whom Lawrence was actually speaking. Strip the God out and you have a dishwashing technique. Keep the God in and you have a life poured out as a prayer.
Thérèse of Lisieux, the Little Flower, died at twenty-four after a brief Carmelite life that produced one of the most influential spiritual autobiographies of the modern era. Her “little way” was a method for offering ordinary annoyances, illnesses, and humiliations to God as love. Her transcendence happens through accepting the cold draft in the laundry without complaint. The economy of grace runs on submission to small irritations. Peak experiences are beside the point.
What these witnesses share is a refusal to make God serve the self. They direct the traffic the other way. The self is to be poured out for God and neighbor. The point of the practice is to become someone capable of loving. Feeling better arrives sometimes as a side effect, and often departs without notice.
What Spirituality Hands You in a Crisis
This is where Cave’s argument lands hardest, because Cave has been in the crisis.
When Arthur died, what did he have. A community that knew the rituals. A church where people had been singing the same words over caskets for centuries. A faith he wasn’t sure about, with a vocabulary for the unbearable. A God who, on Christian terms, had himself watched a son die.
The alternative would’ve been a meditation app reminding him to breathe, an Instagram therapist on the importance of self-care, a stack of books on grief work, and a wellness retreat where someone would tell him his son’s spirit lives on in the trees.
Jonathan Sacks, the late Chief Rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth, used to make this point about the Jewish practice of shiva. After a death, the community comes to you. They sit on low chairs. They speak only when you speak. They cover the mirrors. They bring food. They stay for seven days. The structure carries the grief that the bereaved alone could not carry. Sacks’s argument was that a society that has lost these structures has not freed people. It has stranded them.
Marilynne Robinson, in Gilead and across her essays, keeps returning to a similar point about Calvinist tradition. The Reformed theology she inherited has a category for human depravity, for grace, for vocation, for the dignity of ordinary work done for God. These are sturdy categories. They can hold a life. The spiritual-but-not-religious replacements tend to be thinner. They affirm without anchoring.
David Bentley Hart, with the polemical voltage he’s known for, has argued in The Experience of God and elsewhere that contemporary spirituality is theologically illiterate. People reject a god the Christian tradition also rejects: the celestial old man, the deistic clockmaker, the genie who answers prayer requests. Having rejected this caricature, they imagine they’ve rejected God. What they’ve rejected is a fourth-grade picture book. Real theology, Hart insists, is older, stranger, and more demanding. It outlasts the wellness aisle and everything that comes after.
The Jesus Way
Here is where the argument turns from critique into something constructive.
Eugene Peterson, the pastor and translator who gave us The Message, spent a late book working out a phrase: the Jesus Way. His argument was that Jesus said he is the Way. The thing you follow is a person walking somewhere, and following means walking where he walked, eating what he ate, praying as he prayed, loving as he loved.
This phrase points to the integration that the wellness aisle and the dead church both miss.
Look at what Jesus actually did. He went into the wilderness alone for forty days. He climbed mountains before dawn to pray by himself. He taught in parables that worked like Zen koans, splitting the listener open. He spoke about being one with the Father in language so intimate it scandalized the religious authorities of his day. By any honest reckoning, Jesus was a mystic.
He was also a rabbi. He attended synagogue every Sabbath. He quoted Torah and the Prophets constantly. He kept Passover. He sent his disciples to prepare meals according to the inherited rituals. He told the cleansed leper to go show himself to the priest and make the required offering. He affirmed the Law down to its smallest letters. By any honest reckoning, Jesus was a religious Jew.
The two were one practice. The mystic was the rabbi was the mystic.
This is the integration. The inner life had infrastructure. The infrastructure had inner life. He prayed alone and then went and ate with sinners. He fasted and then attended weddings. He taught the crowds and then withdrew to the hills. He kept the festivals and broke open their meaning. He honored the temple and predicted its fall and called his own body the new temple.
What he asked of his followers had the same shape. Take up your cross. Pray in your closet where no one sees. And: gather. Break bread. Wash feet. Forgive one another. Bear with one another. Confess your faults to one another. The contemplative belonged inseparably with the communal. You needed both to stay on the Way.
Acts 2 describes what the first followers did once Jesus was gone. “They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and to fellowship, to the breaking of bread and to prayer.” Four things. Teaching, which is tradition and scripture. Fellowship, which is community. Breaking of bread, which is sacrament. Prayer, which is inner life with God. The earliest church had no membrane between spirituality and religion. They were the same word.
The contemplative tradition kept this integration alive when the official church forgot it. The Desert Mothers and Fathers prayed alone in caves, and they also obeyed an abba or amma, and they gathered for Eucharist, and they served pilgrims who arrived hungry. Benedict’s Rule arranges the monk’s whole day around the integration: hours of communal prayer, hours of solitary work, hours of reading scripture, hours of hospitality. Teresa of Avila wrote some of the most exalted mystical theology in human history while founding seventeen reformed convents and dealing with the politics of the Spanish Inquisition. Her ecstasies happened inside an order with rules.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who knew the dead-religion temptation from inside the German state church, wrote Life Togetherabout a small community of seminarians at Finkenwalde. The rhythm he proposed: silent meditation on scripture in the morning, communal prayer, shared meals, individual work, communal Eucharist, evening confession. He insisted that solitude and community needed each other to remain healthy. “Let him who cannot be alone beware of community. Let him who is not in community beware of being alone.” A person who avoided his own company in prayer would poison the group. A person who avoided the group would shrivel in solitude. The Jesus Way required both.
Howard Thurman, the African American mystic and theologian whose book Jesus and the Disinherited shaped Martin Luther King Jr., wrote about Jesus as both an inward practice and a political reality. The man on the inner hill talking to his Father was the same man who got himself crucified for siding with the poor. Inner transformation produced public courage. Public courage required inner ground. King prayed, meditated, sang gospel hymns at 3 AM in a Montgomery kitchen alone with God, and then he marched. The integration produced the movement.
This is what Cave keeps reaching for in his Sunday morning visits to small parish churches. The original thing, before the split. A person walking a Way that needs both a heart cracked open and feet that show up to the same building every week. A faith that has room for his doubt and a structure that holds him while he doubts. The candle and the company. The silence and the singing. The bread broken and the body broken and the long memory of a tradition that has loved both.
The wellness aisle sells one half of this. It sells the inner life with no people, no obligations, no shared meal, no buried saints whose prayers continue. The dead church sells the other half. Pews and hymns and committees and no expectation of meeting God in any of it. The Jesus Way is what happens when those two halves recover each other.
You see it in any healthy Christian community where it actually exists. People go to morning prayer at 7 AM and then to the soup kitchen at 10 AM. They read the church fathers and they argue with each other at coffee hour. They take communion every week from the same chipped chalice and they have weeping conversations in the parking lot afterward. They make the sign of the cross and they vote and they bake casseroles for the dying. The mystical and the mundane are the same act. The inner candle and the outer table are the same fire.
This is the case for religion against its spiritual replacements. The replacements give you the candle without the table, or the table without the candle. The Jesus Way gives you both, because that’s what Jesus himself was. A man with God on his lips and bread in his hands and dust on his feet, walking somewhere, asking you to come.
Christianity, Customized
There’s a version of this same trade happening inside the church.
It looks like a Christianity built to taste. Keep Jesus as an inspiring teacher and lose the creeds. Keep prayer as a practice and frame it as self-care. Keep the contemplative traditions of the desert and the cloister and skip the asceticism that produced them. Keep the language of forgiveness and treat repentance as therapeutic baggage. Keep the resurrection as a metaphor for new beginnings. Keep Christmas and Easter. Skip Lent. Skip the fast. Skip the confession. Skip the parts about denying yourself and taking up your cross.
Bonhoeffer had a name for this seventy-five years before the spirituality industry existed. He called it cheap grace. He wrote The Cost of Discipleship while watching his own church capitulate to Hitler, and the first chapter is a diagnosis of how a religion can keep all its outward forms and lose its soul. Cheap grace, he said, is grace without discipleship, baptism without church discipline, communion without confession, absolution without personal confession. It’s grace without the cross. It’s grace treated as a commodity that the possessor enjoys without obligation to live differently. The German church of the 1930s could quote scripture and run Sunday services and produce theological treatises and still march in step with the regime, because the grace they preached cost them nothing.
The mechanism is the same as the wellness aisle. You select the parts that appeal. You leave the parts that demand. You arrange the practices into a configuration that affirms the life you were already going to live. You keep the iconography and drop the obedience. The shape on the outside looks recognizably Christian. The shape on the inside is whatever the customer wanted in the first place.
The contemplative practices are particularly easy to extract this way. The desert mothers and fathers fled to the wastes of Egypt because they thought the post-Constantinian church had grown too comfortable. They prayed for hours at a stretch, fasted to the bone, slept on stone, kept silence for months at a time. Their practices were built to demolish the ego, to strip the self down to what could stand before God. When those same practices are imported by a contemporary Christian as part of a balanced wellness routine, they do the opposite. They reinforce the self. They become another credential, another evidence of seriousness, another way to feel spiritually accomplished without being spiritually demanded.
Julian of Norwich didn’t have a meditation practice. Julian was bricked into a cell. Brother Lawrence didn’t have a mindfulness routine. Brother Lawrence washed dishes for forty years and called it loving God. Thérèse of Lisieux didn’t have a self-care morning ritual. Thérèse was dying of tuberculosis at twenty-four and offering it as love. Every one of the witnesses the contemporary spiritual marketplace draws from lived inside a structure of obedience that the marketplace can’t import. Their practices are inseparable from their submission. To have what they had requires doing what they did.
This is the temptation inside the church, and it travels under many names. Progressive Christianity. Spiritual but not religious. Deconstructed faith. Cultural Christianity. Whatever the label, the operation underneath is the same: keep the bits that comfort, drop the bits that confront. Read the Sermon on the Mount as poetry. Treat the Eucharist as a community gathering. Hold doctrine loosely. Hold community lighter. Keep the option to leave when the church asks for something costly.
A Christianity that keeps the practices and drops the demands belongs in the wellness aisle with a cross-shaped sticker on the front. It carries no more weight than the unmarked product on the next shelf. When the son dies, when the marriage breaks, when the diagnosis arrives, the cross-shaped sticker peels off. What remains is whatever was actually formed in the soul during the years of light commitment. Usually not much.
For the Christian reader, the hard question lies closer to home. Is your own Christianity structurally different from the wellness aisle? Have you let your faith make claims on your time, your money, your sexuality, your enemies, your speech? Have you submitted your life to a community that can correct you? Have you let scripture interrogate you instead of selecting from it? Have you stayed when the church asked something of you that you didn’t want to give? If the honest answer is no, then the candle Cave is reaching for isn’t lit in your church either. You’re visiting the same store as everyone else. You just have a different brand on the bag.
The Hardness Is the Point
Pull this thread together and you get something close to a thesis. Spirituality, as it currently exists in the wellness market, offers the consolations of religion while removing the conditions that made those consolations actual. It offers community without obligation to people you didn’t choose. Ritual without the inconvenience of the calendar. Transcendence without submission. Grace without judgment. Meaning without truth claims. A god without teeth.
For ordinary good weather, this might be sufficient. The trouble comes when the weather turns.
When a child dies, when the diagnosis arrives, when the marriage ends, when the failure is total and public, when the years stretch into a dark night of the soul, the customer-facing version of the sacred offers only consolations that curdle into insult. Telling a grieving father that the universe has a plan, that everything happens for a reason, that he should focus on his own healing, that his son’s soul is now part of the cosmic energy, is no consolation. It’s a small private cruelty dressed in pastel.
What Cave finds in the church, what the Desert Mothers found in their cells, what Julian found in her anchorhold, what Thérèse found in her laundry, is a tradition that has been to the bottom and reports back. It walks into the dark with you, holding a thin candle whose light is older than your grief.
The candle has been burning, by relay, for two thousand years.
It’s a small light. It pretends to be exactly what it is. The flame has held people through plagues, wars, famines, the deaths of countless children, the slow accumulated betrayals of ordinary life. It outlasts the meditation app. It outlasts the bookstore section. It outlasts the algorithm.
This is what religion holds that spirituality drops. Something firmer than a feeling. A claim. That the universe is in the hands of a love that has bled. That the demand made on you, hard as it is, is the demand of that love. That when you walk into the cold stone church and light your candle and say the old words you don’t quite believe, you’re joining something real.
Cave doesn’t say he believes all this with certainty. He says he keeps showing up. He says the showing up has done something to him that nothing else has done. He says the candle does something the app cannot do.
The argument, in the end, comes to that. To the candle, and the cold stone, and the company of the dead, and the small flame that has not gone out.
* * *
Bibliography
Augustine of Hippo. Confessions. Translated by Henry Chadwick. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1991.
Bonhoeffer, Dietrich. The Cost of Discipleship. Translated by R. H. Fuller. New York: Touchstone, 1995.
Bonhoeffer, Dietrich. Life Together. Translated by John W. Doberstein. New York: Harper & Row, 1954.
Burton, Tara Isabella. Strange Rites: New Religions for a Godless World. New York: PublicAffairs, 2020.
Cave, Nick. The Red Hand Files. Accessed May 18, 2026. https://www.theredhandfiles.com/.
Cave, Nick, and Seán O’Hagan. Faith, Hope and Carnage. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2022.
Hart, David Bentley. The Experience of God: Being, Consciousness, Bliss. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2013.
John of the Cross. Dark Night of the Soul. Translated by E. Allison Peers. Mineola, NY: Dover Publications, 2003.
Julian of Norwich. Revelations of Divine Love. Translated by Elizabeth Spearing. London: Penguin Classics, 1998.
Lawrence of the Resurrection. The Practice of the Presence of God. Translated by John J. Delaney. New York: Image Books, 1977.
Peterson, Eugene H. The Jesus Way: A Conversation on the Ways That Jesus Is the Way. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2007.
Robinson, Marilynne. Gilead. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2004.
Robinson, Marilynne. The Death of Adam: Essays on Modern Thought. New York: Picador, 2005.
Sacks, Jonathan. Morality: Restoring the Common Good in Divided Times. New York: Basic Books, 2020.
Sacks, Jonathan. The Dignity of Difference: How to Avoid the Clash of Civilizations. London: Continuum, 2002.
Taylor, Charles. A Secular Age. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007.
Thérèse of Lisieux. Story of a Soul: The Autobiography of St. Thérèse of Lisieux. Translated by John Clarke. 3rd ed. Washington, DC: ICS Publications, 1996.
Thurman, Howard. Jesus and the Disinherited. Boston: Beacon Press, 1996.
Ward, Benedicta, trans. The Sayings of the Desert Fathers: The Alphabetical Collection. Kalamazoo, MI: Cistercian Publications, 1984.
Photo by Marcos Paulo Prado on Unsplash
