In some corners of the church, empathy is treated with suspicion. Critics argue that it makes us vulnerable to manipulation or risks replacing truth with sentiment. They say that empathy can slide into permissiveness, blurring moral clarity. Others fear it elevates human feelings above divine revelation.
These cautions aren’t trivial. It’d be easy for me to dismiss them out of hand, but I don’t want to do that. Empathy untethered from truth can collapse into indulgence. Compassion that never discerns can excuse cruelty. But to dismiss empathy altogether is to miss one of the deepest gifts of Christian spirituality: the invitation to feel with others in a way that mirrors the heart of Christ.
“Christlike empathy isn’t sentimentality; it’s vision born from the suffering love of Christ.”
Christian empathy isn’t mere sentimentality. It’s the fruit of incarnation. It flows from a God who didn’t remain distant but entered flesh and frailty, who bore wounds, hunger, thirst, and rejection. To follow Christ is to enter into this same movement of self-emptying love, to listen with the ears of the heart, and to stand where others stand, not as saviors, but as companions.
“Empathy rooted in Christ isn’t weakness. It’s cruciform strength: the courage to let another’s pain pierce us without rushing to defend ourselves.”
The Incarnation as Divine Empathy
The birth of Jesus in a Bethlehem stable wasn’t simply a divine strategy for salvation. It was an act of such profound solidarity that it redefined the concept of holiness. The infinite took on the cries of an infant. The One through whom galaxies were formed knew what it was to be hungry, weary, misunderstood, betrayed.
The incarnation is empathy embodied. In Christ, God doesn’t look at suffering from afar but steps into the texture of it. This isn’t empathy as a technique or mood, but as an ontology: God with us.
When Christians practice empathy, we imitate the God who became touchable. We echo the mystery of Emmanuel. Our willingness to see through another’s eyes, to feel the weight of another’s burden, isn’t a departure from the Gospel but its enactment.
This reshapes our imagination of holiness. Holiness isn’t separation from human sorrow but immersion in it. It’s compassion that risks contamination, love that breaks down barriers. The God who touched lepers, dined with sinners, and wept at a tomb is the same God who calls disciples to do likewise.
Crucifixion and Wounded Empathy
If the incarnation shows us God’s nearness, the crucifixion shows us God’s wound. On the cross, Jesus bore more than nails. He bore the derision of empire, the betrayal of friends, the loneliness of abandonment. Here, empathy isn’t optional. It’s salvific.
The crucifixion reveals the myth that empathy is a sign of weakness. Empathy at the cross is costly. It doesn’t avert its gaze from pain. It doesn’t shield itself from the anguish of another. It lets the world’s grief break the heart.
This is why Christian empathy is different from mere emotional resonance. It isn’t about indulging feelings but about standing in solidarity with those who suffer. It shares not only joys but sorrows. It risks not only compassion but cruciform vulnerability.
“The cross teaches us that empathy isn’t a skill we deploy but a sacrifice we embody. It costs blood, tears, and presence.”
The Resurrection as Redeemed Empathy
If the cross reveals divine solidarity in suffering, the resurrection reveals divine hope in companionship. Empathy doesn’t end at the grave. When the risen Christ met Mary Magdalene outside the tomb, when he walked unrecognized with disciples on the road, when he cooked breakfast for weary friends by the sea, he showed that love doesn’t abandon.
Resurrection empathy isn’t pity. It’s presence that breathes new life. It listens to despair yet refuses to concede to it. It looks at the wounds yet proclaims that death doesn’t have the last word.
This hope saves empathy from collapsing into despair. To feel deeply without hope is to drown. To feel deeply with resurrection in view is to rise with others, even when the rising is slow, fragile, and hidden.
Mystical Tradition and Empathy
The mystical tradition of the church often speaks of union: union with God, union with others, union with creation. To practice empathy is to live out this union in the ordinary. It’s to perceive the image of God shimmering in another, to sense the Spirit groaning with those who groan.
Mystics remind us that empathy begins in silence. Only when we descend into the inner stillness can we hold the cries of others without judgment or defensiveness. Empathy is prayer before it’s practice. It’s contemplation that opens into communion.
This inner grounding protects empathy from distortion. Without contemplative depth, empathy can become co-dependency or collapse into burnout. But when rooted in the inexhaustible love of Christ, empathy becomes a wellspring that doesn’t run dry.
The Prophetic Edge of Empathy
Empathy in Christ isn’t passive. It not only sits quietly with the grieving but also rises to confront the forces that cause grief. Genuine empathy fuels justice. To feel the hunger of people experiencing poverty is to demand bread. To feel the fear of the undocumented is to demand safety. To feel the trauma of the oppressed is to cry out for liberation.
This is why some resist empathy: it disrupts comfort. It calls for change. It doesn’t allow us to remain neutral. When Jesus wept over Jerusalem, his tears weren’t only for personal sorrow but for a city bent on destruction. His lament carried prophetic fire.
“Christlike empathy isn’t sentiment that soothes the status quo. It’s sanctified sight that exposes injustice, and love that insists on transformation.”
The Concerns of Misguided Empathy
But the cautions deserve attention. There’s a way of practicing empathy that can lose its way. It can excuse sin by refusing to name it. It can mirror others’ feelings so entirely that it abandons discernment. It can become so identified with another that it no longer points to Christ.
Christian spirituality insists that empathy must be yoked to truth. To feel with someone isn’t to affirm every choice they make. To sit with another’s pain isn’t to bless the structures that perpetuate it. The balance is delicate: compassion without compromise, solidarity without surrender.
This balance is possible only because empathy isn’t self-generated but Spirit-breathed. It’s Christ in us, the hope of glory, who makes us able to bear with one another without being consumed.
Responding to the Concerns about Empathy
Some Christians worry that empathy can lead us astray. They fear it might cause us to compromise truth for the sake of compassion, to blur moral boundaries because we’ve entered too deeply into another’s experience. Empathy, they say, risks being guided more by feelings than by faith, more by sentiment than by Scripture. Others worry that carrying the pain of others will overwhelm and exhaust, leaving disciples paralyzed instead of prayerful. Still others suspect that an overemphasis on empathy could shift the focus of the Christian life from obedience to God toward the shifting emotions of human relationships.
These aren’t trivial concerns. They arise from a desire to guard faithfulness. They name a real danger: the human heart can be seduced by what feels merciful but may not lead to holiness. Compassion without wisdom can become complicity. A spirituality that listens only to human cries without grounding itself in divine truth risks becoming mired in confusion. To dismiss these cautions outright would be unfaithful to the tradition of discernment that has always been part of Christian spirituality.
When we look at Jesus Christ, we discover empathy as the very path God chose for redemption. The incarnation shows God refusing distance and entering human experience fully and vulnerably. In Christ, divinity bore flesh, walked dusty roads, shared meals, wept at gravesides, and carried betrayal in the body. Empathy here isn’t sentimental excess; it’s the mystery of incarnation.
The cross intensifies this revelation. At Golgotha, Jesus took the world’s suffering into himself. Human pain and violence weren’t merely witnessed; they were borne. God didn’t suspend judgment nor avoid truth; Christ Jesus fulfilled both as he shouldered sin’s consequence in love. Empathy in this light doesn’t dilute conviction. It grounds truth more deeply, making it tangible in wounds and mercy. To see through another’s eyes is to allow truth to take form in flesh, to breathe through compassion.
The life of Jesus also reveals empathy as a source of power for action. Compassion moved him to heal the sick, feed the hungry, defend the outcast, and confront oppressive powers. Christian empathy, therefore, can’t remain passive. It listens deeply, but then it carries bread. It feels the wound, and then it binds. It attends to the cry, and then it steps forward into costly love.
Obedience to Christ makes empathy essential. The command to love God and neighbor demands that we enter the joys and sorrows of others just as Christ entered ours. To carry another’s pain is to walk the road Jesus walked, the road of the crucified and risen one who embraced all that is human with redeeming love.
Rooted in the gospel, empathy reveals the holiness of God. It embodies incarnate love where truth and mercy meet. It listens without surrendering discernment, and it acts with a courage that accepts cost. Such empathy, shaped by the cross, doesn’t leave us overwhelmed by tears; it immerses us in the living waters of Christ’s compassion, from which justice, healing, and hope rise.
Empathy and the Church
In a fragmented world, the church should be the school of empathy. Here, strangers become neighbors, and neighbors become like family. The Eucharist is empathy made sacrament: one bread broken for many, one cup shared among wounds and joys.
Yet too often, the church mirrors the divisions of the world. Empathy shrivels in echo chambers. We learn to feel only for those who look like us, vote like us, and believe like us. But the Spirit is calling the church beyond tribal compassion into cruciform solidarity.
To practice empathy as the body of Christ is to weep with persecuted believers abroad and with victims of racism at home, to rejoice with newly married couples and to ache with those who long for companionship, to sit with the elderly in silence and to sing with the young in joy.
The church without empathy is a clanging cymbal. The church, with empathy, becomes a living body where every member’s suffering and joy are shared.
Empathy and Contemporary Issues
Empathy isn’t abstract. It touches every public question. To follow Christ in the practice of empathy means:
- We empathize with immigrants and refugees. We seek to understand and respond to the peril of the journey, the ache of displacement, the fear of rejection. We welcome with hospitality, not suspicion.
- We empathize with those experiencing poverty. We seek to understand and respond to the hunger of empty stomachs, the humiliation of exclusion, the fatigue of endless labor. We advocate for justice that provides enough.
- We empathize with the marginalized. We seek to understand and respond to the isolation of those excluded for race, orientation, or status. We stand in solidarity, naming dignity where the world denies it.
- We empathize with the planet itself. We seek to understand and respond to the groaning of creation, the scorching forests, the parched lands, the endangered creatures. We live in ways that heal, not exploit.
- With empathize with those we oppose politically, religiously, or culturally. We seek to understand and respond to what drives their choices, and to hear their stories without caricature. We refuse the temptation of contempt.
This doesn’t mean abandoning conviction. It means embodying conviction through compassion. The truth of the Gospel isn’t weakened by empathy. It’s revealed through it.
Empathy as Cruciform Practice
What, then, does it mean to practice empathy shaped by Christian spirituality?
It means listening before speaking.
It means weeping before judging.
It means standing close enough to be pierced by another’s pain.
It means holding stories as sacred, not as arguments to be won.
It means remembering that every person we meet is beloved, bearing the imprint of Christ.
Empathy isn’t a technique but a transformation. It’s the cruciform life poured into daily encounters. It’s the incarnation continued through the body of Christ. It’s resurrection hope refusing despair.
“To practice empathy is to live as if the incarnation happened, as if the cross saves, and as if the resurrection opens the tombs of despair.”
The Kingdom Shaped by Empathy
Christian nationalism seeks power without compassion. Secular pragmatism seeks results without relationship. Empathy rooted in Christ offers another way: a kingdom where love listens, where presence heals, where wounds aren’t hidden but shared.
The church is called to be this kind of community: not sentimental but sacramental, not indulgent but incarnational, not captive to ideologies but shaped by the wounds and wisdom of Jesus.
Empathy in Christ isn’t optional. It’s discipleship. To refuse empathy is to refuse incarnation. To embrace empathy is to embrace the God who embraced us.
And when the church embodies this, the world will see not just a community that feels, but a kingdom that loves with the very heart of God.
Bibliography
Athanasius. On the Incarnation. Translated by John Behr. Yonkers: St. Vladimir’s Seminary, 2011.
Gutiérrez, Gustavo. A Theology of Liberation: History, Politics, and Salvation. Maryknoll: Orbis, 1988.
Moltmann, Jürgen. The Crucified God: The Cross of Christ as the Foundation and Criticism of Christian Theology. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993.
Nouwen, Henri J.M. Life of the Beloved: Spiritual Living in a Secular World. New York: Crossroad, 1992.
Teresa of Ávila. The Interior Castle. Translated by Mirabai Starr. New York: Riverhead, 2003.
References
[1] Athanasius, On the Incarnation.
[2] Moltmann, The Crucified God.
[3] Teresa of Ávila, The Interior Castle.
[4] Gutiérrez, A Theology of Liberation.
[5] Nouwen, Life of the Beloved.
Cover Image
Cover photo copyright Andrew Hamilton (Yanchep Beaches 365)
See All My 20+ Books
See my books at this link: Graham Joseph Hill books
______________________________________________
Book Update
My book “World Christianity: An Introduction” has been shortlisted for the 2025 Australian Christian Book of the Year award.
See the book at this link: World Christianity: An Introduction
